Jury Trial Defence Lawyer
Facing a jury trial is the most high-stakes and intimidating experience in the criminal justice system. When your freedom, reputation, and future are in the hands of twelve strangers, you cannot afford second-rate representation. Defending serious charges in the District or High Court requires more than just legal knowledge; it demands formidable courtroom advocacy, meticulous preparation, and the ability to compellingly dismantle the Crown’s case. As a specialist criminal defence barrister, I provide relentless, strategic representation for clients facing complex jury trials, ensuring your story is heard and your rights are fiercely protected.
Types of jury trials we handle
Serious Violence & Assault
Defending Category 3 and Category 4 offences, including grievous bodily harm (GBH), kidnapping, and aggravated robbery.
Drug Offending
Complex trials involving allegations of importing, manufacturing, or supplying Class A and B controlled drugs.
Sexual Offences
Providing highly discreet, rigorous defence for serious historical and contemporary sexual allegations.
Major Fraud & Financial Crime
Deconstructing complex financial evidence and prosecuting narratives in high-level white-collar crime trials.
Elected Jury Trials
Advising on the strategic benefits of electing a judge-alone trial versus a jury trial for eligible offences carrying a penalty of two or more years' imprisonment.
Contact us
Meticulous Trial Preparation
Skilful Cross-Examination
Persuasive Advocacy
Navigating the jury trial process in New Zealand
A jury trial is a marathon, not a sprint. The Crown bears the ultimate burden of proof: they must prove their case against you beyond a reasonable doubt. Our strategy is designed to hold the prosecution to that strict standard at every phase of the process:
1. Pre-Trial Arguments
We fight to level the playing field before the jury is even selected. This includes arguing to exclude unfairly obtained evidence, challenging police interview methods, or seeking severance if you are being unfairly tried alongside co-defendants.
2. Jury Selection (Empanelling)
Selecting a fair and impartial jury is critical. We utilize our legal right to challenge potential jurors to ensure the panel hearing your case is as objective and unbiased as possible.
3. Defence Case & Witnesses
You are never required to prove your innocence, but where advantageous, we will present a robust affirmative defence. This may involve calling our own expert witnesses, such as medical professionals or forensic accountants, and advising you strategically on whether giving evidence in your own defence is the right tactical move.
4. The Verdict
We stand by you through the immense pressure of jury deliberations, ensuring the judge's final directions to the jury are legally sound and entirely fair to your defence.
Jury trial FAQs
For many offences carrying two years or more in prison, yes, you can elect a jury trial under the Criminal Procedure Act 2011. Your lawyer can talk you through whether that's the right call for your case.
It varies a lot depending on the charges and how many witnesses are involved. Straightforward matters might run a few days, while complex trials, like serious fraud or multiple charges, can take weeks.
This is called a hung jury. If the jury can't agree, the judge may discharge them, and the Crown then decides whether to seek a retrial with a new jury.
No. You have the right to remain silent throughout your trial, and the jury cannot hold it against you if you choose not to give evidence.
It depends on the case. Some matters, especially those relying heavily on community standards or credibility, can suit a jury. Others, particularly technical or document heavy cases, might be better suited to a judge alone. It's a strategic decision worth discussing properly with your lawyer.
Recent Case Outcomes
A selection of recent murder and jury trial cases Annabel has successfully defended.
Convicted at trial in a complex murder case. The conviction was ultimately overturned and our client acquitted on appeal.
Accused of murdering his father. Acquitted of both murder and manslaughter at trial.